I'm in the process of constructing a new home and have already installed the furnace and AC. Now I'm focusing on the water heater setup. My house has 5 full bathrooms, 1 powder room, and about 700 sq ft of heated floor piping in the basement with hot water recirculation plumbing already completed. I'm looking for the best water heating solution that can provide enough hot water for faucets, showers, and the basement flooring, ensuring fast access to hot water and the ability for two people to take long hot showers simultaneously.
I received a quote from Reliance, a rental company in Canada, for a 75-gallon tank (PV 75 by Bradford White), but that seemed a bit basic at $56/month. Go Lime inspected my setup and recommended a Navien combi boiler, along with an indirect storage tank, expansion tank, water backflow prevention, and a recirculating pump for $125/month. Which solution do you think is the right choice?
2 Answers
Honestly, it’s really about your usage. If you’re having a lot of people using hot water at the same time, the boiler system is probably the way to go. Renting systems can seem sketchy in the long run, but make sure to factor in what kind of warranties and service plans each option offers. The long-term benefits might justify the extra cost with the Go Lime system.
It sounds like you have a pretty complex setup, and both options have their merits. If you go with the Reliance 75-gallon tank, it might be fine for your needs, but the Go Lime proposal sounds more robust. A combi boiler is efficient and can definitely meet your simultaneous hot water needs better than a standard tank. Plus, the recirculating pump will help reduce the wait for hot water, which is a plus for large homes. I'd lean towards the Go Lime option for overall performance, even if it's a bit pricier.
Yeah, I agree. I had a similar situation and went with a combi boiler and haven't regretted it since. The efficiency and quick heat-up have been lifesavers, especially with a family.
Good point! Make sure to think about maintenance down the line, too. A good service plan can make a huge difference.