I recently got a Bench Dog 60-1/2 Block Plane and sharpened the blade, but it's not performing as I expected. I needed a hand plane for my woodworking projects, but since I'm new to the craft and short on cash, I opted for this one instead of spending on a more expensive model. After taking it to a local lumber shop, the experts there pointed out it had a bent mouth and the blade wasn't square, so they replaced it for me. However, the new one still isn't working right—it just tears up the wood, regardless of the type. What can I do to fix this? I'm really in need of some advice, as I can't afford a gorgeous tool right now!
5 Answers
Ensure your blade is really sharp, especially if you're dealing with odd grain. How confident are you with the whole sharpening process? It makes a big difference!
Yeah, I’m asking about the Bench Dog 60-1/2 that costs around $110. Honestly, it’s not a great budget choice since you can get premium ones for a bit more that work flawlessly out of the box (like a Lie Nielsen for about 50 bucks more). If you're planning to do hand milling, I'd suggest aiming for a #4 or #5. You might find better options from places like Hyperkitten tools or Jim Bode. You can potentially grab a nice, workable used one for under $100. Plus, you’ll need sharpening tools regardless, so keep that in mind!
Honestly, I think the 60-1/2 isn't that bad. With some tuning, it could be made quite usable. I’ve managed with worse planes! Try using a clean piece of poplar or nicer pine to tune it effectively; it'll be much easier than on rough 2x lumber.
First off, double-check that your blade is bevel up, and make sure the mouth is set close to the blade. When setting your blade depth, try small adjustments of 1/8 to 1/4 turns until it barely touches the wood, then run it along a piece for shavings. Remember, when working with rough lumber, you might need to do a lot of planing before you get those nice shavings you're looking for. Just takes some patience!
Thanks for the tips! I’ll definitely be more careful with the adjustments. But even with all this, I’ve heard from others that these planes aren’t great. Should I consider upgrading the blade or maybe try restoring an older plane to avoid all this hassle?
If you’re really tight on budget, connect with local collectors in your area, like the Pacific Northwest Tool Collectors. They usually have a range of tools at reasonable prices that might be a better fit for you. Check them out!
Yes, I saw it on Rockler! I’m based in PNW, so I’ll definitely check those places you recommended. I’d love a #5 but not a new one—if I can find a good used one for around $100, that’s the way to go!