I'm planning a remodeling project for my upstairs bathroom, which is currently a standard setup with a tub, tile, and shower curtain. The existing tiles are damaged due to water issues from the previous owner's lack of maintenance, and I've decided it's time for some serious upgrades, including replacing tiles, potential studs, and definitely cement board. I can manage the work myself, including plumbing, and I have the budget for it. My wife adores the idea of a clawfoot tub and enjoys taking baths, but this is also our main shower, and we have a full bathroom downstairs that's rarely used. I need some honest feedback on whether installing a clawfoot tub is a good idea or if I might end up regretting it.
6 Answers
I grew up with a clawfoot tub; they are stylish but not the best for everyday showering. If you're set on one, I suggest having a dedicated shower nearby. Regular tubs, while less flashy, are much easier to maintain, and water won’t sneak into hard-to-reach spots.
Clawfoot tubs are fantastic for baths, but showering in them can be a pain! They are tough to step in and out of, and there isn’t much space to stand. If you decide to go for it, I recommend creating a separate wet area with a traditional shower setup.
Stepping in and out of a clawfoot tub can be tricky, especially as we get older. They're deeper than most standard tubs, which might not be ideal if you're planning to age in place. If you really want one, you might want to consider a special setup that offers easier access.
One thing to keep in mind is the weight distribution. Clawfoot tubs concentrate the weight on small points, so make sure your floor can handle it. You might want to consider reinforced framing or using larger feet for better support.
Before you commit to a clawfoot tub, consider whether you have a backup shower option. I had one in my previous home, and it caused a huge mess every time I showered. Water got everywhere! If you really want it, think about tiling the entire area and adding a glass half-door to minimize the water splash. They look gorgeous but are a hassle to deal with when you actually use them for showers.
I haven’t owned one myself, but I see some big drawbacks. First off, maintenance is a pain; you'll need to clean under and behind it regularly. Plus, the plumbing is exposed, making it less tidy. If you’re thinking of using it for showers, a wraparound curtain is essential unless you want a soaking wet floor. Also, when you shower, the tub’s shape might feel cramped compared to standard showers.