I'm in a bit of a dilemma here! I own a small two-bedroom, one-bath apartment-like home, and I'm considering swapping out the old tub in my bathroom for a stylish shower unit. I've heard mixed opinions about this—some say it might hurt the resale value when it comes time to sell. I'm curious if anyone has insight on this—do people still prefer having a bathtub over just a shower, especially in a smaller living space?
3 Answers
Some people really do prefer baths! I remember when we bought our last house, we skipped over places without tubs right away—my wife loves her bubble baths. The resale aspect is important, especially if you plan on renting or selling. You'll want to keep that in mind.
That's so true! Tubs also appeal to a wider audience. Think about families—they really value having that option.
Honestly, if you're not planning on moving soon, do what makes you feel good in your home! Just think about the potential buyers down the line. Removing the tub might close off options. But if this is your forever home or you’re content with your renovation, no worries! Just balance your happiness with any future selling strategies.
Right? I say ditch the tub if you truly don't need it; it's your space after all! Plus, if it's going to result in a gorgeous shower, that's a win.
True, but just a heads-up—some buyers might use that against you when negotiating if they're looking for a family-friendly space.
You've got a valid concern! For smaller homes like a 2/1, the buyer market can be quite limited. While some buyers might not mind a shower-only setup, many young couples or families typically look for at least one tub, especially if they have kids or plan to in the future. If you’re going to stay for a while, go ahead and upgrade to what makes you happy; just keep the resale perspective in mind!
I agree! When we were house hunting, we didn't even consider homes without bathtubs. It's true that they can be essential for families with little ones.
Totally! Even if you don't need it yourself, a tub can be handy for washing pets or cleaning large items.

Exactly! Plus, some people use tubs for more than just bathing. They're useful for cleaning dogs or for crafts.