I've been woodworking with power tools for a long time but started transitioning to hand tools about a year to a year and a half ago. Initially, I bought a cheap workbench from Harbor Freight to learn on, knowing I would eventually want to build a better one once I had more experience. Fast forward to now, and I'm ready to light that flimsy bench on fire! I want to build a new, sturdy bench that fits my needs.
I've been considering the Paul Sellers bench because it seems to address a lot of my complaints with my current setup, and I've learned many techniques from his videos. But then I stumbled upon the Anarchist Workbench, and I'm finding its arguments compelling.
I'm aiming to make the right choices here, so I have a few specific areas I'm curious about:
- **Vise**: My instinct was to go with a cast iron quick-release, but I'm intrigued by leg vises. Is it as cumbersome as it looks?
- **Apron**: Some swear by it, while others want to toss it out. What's the real deal?
- **Tool Wells**: Do they actually help or just create a mess? Given I'm somewhat disorganized, would a tool well be beneficial or a big waste of space?
Basically, if you've built either of these benches, I'd love to hear your thoughts and any regrets you might have. Ultimately, I want to design something that really works for me. Thanks for any guidance!
3 Answers
I built the Anarchist Workbench, and honestly, it's been a game-changer. The leg vise is fantastic for various tasks and provides a firm grip. My tool well is currently half-filled with junk, so I'd say it depends on the person. Just keep it clear, and it can be quite helpful! If you're going with features from both benches, consider what works best for your routine. Also, don't stress it too much; your bench will evolve as you grow in your woodworking journey!
I've built the Paul Sellers workbench and it's been great for me! Though I don't do a ton of woodworking, it's sturdy enough for a variety of projects. The tool well is actually quite useful, keeping essential tools within reach without crowding my space. As for the apron, it's not a game-changer, but it does add some stability to the bench. Just make sure to use a good quality material to avoid warping, like I did with my lamination mistake!
Thanks for sharing! I hadn’t thought about how the apron could affect stability when clamping. That's good to know!
I did a lot of research before settling on the English Workbench by Richard Maguire instead, but I can see the merits of both. I found that the leg vise on the Anarchist Workbench really helps with edge jointing and dovetails. On the downside, it's a bit tougher to build if you're reliant on hand tools. But if you can swing it, I would recommend going that route for a solid, long-lasting bench.
Interesting choice! I like the idea of a sturdy leg vise. It sounds like it could really enhance my workflow.
Glad to hear that! I’m definitely leaning toward the Anarchist because of the versatility. I appreciate the reminder that it’s okay to modify my setup as I go!