I recently purchased a home that likely still has the original water heater from when it was built in 2004. It's showing signs of wear with a previous leak and probably hasn't been flushed ever. I can only enjoy about one decent-length shower before running out of hot water, so it's definitely time for a replacement. I'm currently using a gas-powered tank system, and since I'm in the Pacific Northwest where power outages are rare, I'm wondering if I should stick to a similar setup or consider other options. What recommendations do you all have for replacement water heaters, and what factors should influence my choice?
3 Answers
Finding the best price for parts and labor is crucial. I suggest calling local plumbing wholesalers since they often have great recommendations for reliable plumbers. You’ll get better service and fair prices. Also, don’t hesitate to ring a few plumbers yourself and get quotes—this can help you compare costs and find the best deal!
If you're thinking of a replacement, I'd highly recommend going for a heat pump water heater (HPWH) instead of another gas unit. It’s a better choice for the environment, and you might score some local rebates plus a federal tax credit this year (though that might change after 2026). It's great for energy efficiency, especially here in the Pacific Northwest. Plus, I know people in California who've had success navigating these upgrades, so you might find resources helpful. Check out local programs for assistance!
I had to swap mine out last year and it was a pain, honestly. I went with a 50-gallon gas tank, supposedly good for a family of five. I got about three quotes, with each around $2500 including everything—removal, installation, and permits. If I ever need to do it again, I might just tackle it myself. Just make sure to vet your professionals carefully!