I'm transforming part of my basement into a woodshop, and the first project is to build a workbench. For this, I need a couple of planes: a 62 1/2 low angle jack plane and a 60 1/2 block plane. I've been researching options and am considering Stanley Sweetheart planes, which seem solid for the price. There's also a local vintage tool dealer who restores and sells tools—he typically has several restored 62 1/2 and 60 1/2 planes available for a similar price to new Stanley Sweethearts, possibly a little more.
Alternatively, I could save up and invest in new Lie Nielsen planes, which would definitely be heirloom quality and appealing to me. I suspect that many people will recommend the vintage route, which also supports a guy doing important work in restoring these tools for new craftsmen. However, I'm weighing the pros and cons of known quality at lower prices from Stanley Sweetheart versus the assurance of quality with Lie Nielsen. What's everyone's take: Stanley Sweetheart, vintage tools, or Lie Nielsen?
3 Answers
It really comes down to your budget. I usually pick up cheaper tools until I'm sold on the need for better quality. Most of my hand tools are used, and that’s worked out well for me. You might want to check out www.jimbodetools.com for some good options!
If you’re just picking one bench plane, I'd avoid bevel-up planes. You can find good vintage 62s, or for a similar price, grab a 4 and a 5 in great condition. It might give you more versatility for your workbench project.
Honestly, it really depends on your situation. I went with Lie Nielsen for most of my planes because I love having tools that are ready to use right out of the box. With kids running around, I can’t spare the time to restore vintage planes or sift through listings online, plus I want something solid I can pass down. Everyone’s journey is unique, so figure out what fits your needs best!