I'm hoping to get some advice on keeping screws and nails in my walls. I suspect my walls are made of drywall with a layer of plaster typical of homes built in the '80s. Every time I try to insert a screw or nail, they just pop out after a short time. Even drywall anchors aren't working for me, even when I make sure the pilot hole is smaller than the anchor itself. I aim to hang items on studs whenever possible, but that's not always an option—like when I need to support a curtain rod in the middle of a large window or set up shelf brackets. Sometimes, when the screw or nail comes out, it seems like the wall crumbles, but usually, it just pops out cleanly. Since I'm a homeowner, I'd like to find a lasting solution to this persistent issue!
3 Answers
Have you considered using toggle bolts? They can handle a lot more weight and provide better stability in walls like yours, especially if the drywall is loosely adhering to the plaster. Just make sure to follow the instructions for installation to get the best results!
You might want to try using different types of anchors. There are many out there designed for different loads and wall types. Some are definitely better than the standard plugs that come with things you purchase—especially with curtain rods. Those often include some of the worst anchors. Head to your local hardware store and pick up some high-quality ones; they will make a big difference!
It’s common for older houses to have drywall over plaster, especially if someone tried to update it. If you indeed have plaster and lath behind the drywall, there will be some wooden strips that should be able to support light items with regular wood screws. Figuring out what's actually behind your walls is crucial for knowing what hardware to use.