I'm remodeling my bathroom due to a leak from an old toilet seal. I've managed to lay down the underlayment and tile, but I've just discovered that I might have messed up the toilet flange installation. I got an Oatey screw-to-fit flange with a little gasket, but I think I was supposed to remove a metal piece feeding into the pipe first. The 3" flange I have seems too small, and the 4" is too big. Is there a way to fix this without having to take up my tile? Also, I know my tiling job isn't the best—this home improvement project has become quite the challenge for me!
2 Answers
I think you won't have to rip everything out if it's just a height issue! Make sure the flange is set at the right height so that it’s level with the tile. If your current flange isn’t working, a flange spacer set is a great option. I’d recommend checking local hardware stores for them. Just ensure it’s all watertight with silicone before you put the toilet back!
This can totally be salvaged! The best way to handle this situation is to install the flange at the correct height on top of the finished tile. Here’s what I suggest:
1. Use some plastic flange spacers to build the flange up level with your tile (just don't raise it too high or the toilet won't fit).
2. Place the twist-set flange on top of the spacers.
3. Pre-drill small pilot holes aligned with the mounting holes because you'll need to screw into that old metal flange.
4. Don’t forget to scrape and vacuum up any dust before applying a generous amount of clear silicone caulk around the area. You want everything under the toilet to be waterproof to avoid future leaks ruining your tile!
5. Finally, secure the flange to the subfloor with exterior deck screws, preferably stainless steel to avoid rust.
Thanks for the reassurance! I’ll definitely check out those flange spacers and follow the waterproofing tips. I just want to get this bathroom done!