I've been working on smaller woodworking projects like shelves and guitar bodies, using a #4 plane and a straight block plane so far. Now I'm looking to tackle a media console and a medium-sized table made of oak, which makes me think I need a larger plane for tasks like flattening and rough cuts.
I'm contemplating whether to go for a #5 1/2 or a #6, as I want to ensure that this additional plane can handle anything larger than my #4. Since I live in Norway, my local shops stock mostly #4s and the occasional #5, so I can't try them out in person before buying one online. I'm looking for advice from more experienced woodworkers on whether a #5 1/2 is sufficient for flattening larger boards (up to 150cm), or if a #6 would be too bulky for finer work. Any insights would be appreciated!
3 Answers
I think a #6 would do just fine for your projects. While both #6 and #5 1/2 are great options, the #6 is particularly good for larger projects because it offers more length, which helps in achieving a flat surface on wider boards. You can definitely use the #6 effectively as a jack plane. If you're only looking for one more plane, it might be the best fit. Just keep in mind that you’ll want to get a good sharpening setup to maximize its performance!
Exactly! If you're mainly focusing on one new addition, a #6 could cover your needs without leaving gaps in your collection.
From what you've described, a #5 1/2 could work well too! It's versatile enough for flattening and shooting tasks without being overwhelmingly large. Lots of woodworkers find it to be a sweet spot between size and usability. That said, if you ever consider getting a #7 in the future, a #5 could also pair nicely with your #4 for your current projects. Each has its own strengths, and if you can, getting your hands on a used one could be a good move.
Yeah, and don’t forget to check local second-hand options—sometimes you can find some real gems!
Thanks for the insights! I'm leaning towards the #5 1/2 since many people seem to be happy with it for their projects.
The #5 1/2 is a great choice if you go that route! It's big enough to handle flattening but still nimble for other tasks. I used one for years and loved it. If you can find a vintage option, even better. But if you’re set on new, I still recommend going for it! Just make sure you’ve got a good sharpening setup, as that's what will really make a difference in its performance.
Good point about the sharpening! I've been meaning to invest in that equipment as well.
Absolutely! A well-sharpened blade makes a world of difference across all your planes.
So you're saying I could manage just with the #4 and the #6? A #5 1/2 might not be necessary in between?