I'm thrilled to be closing on a duplex in Parkside/North Buffalo NY, where the charm of 100-year-old houses meets classic features like hardwood floors and galley kitchens. The downstairs unit hasn't seen updates since the early '90s. To attract better tenants, I plan to renovate the first floor, knowing that rent for similar units typically ranges from $1300 to $1900 per month, plus I'm including an off-street parking spot. The current tile has held up well, but it has a stormy green tone that's more intense than the blue in the photos I took. I want to know: can I create a sleek, modern kitchen with these tiles, or do you think the color might limit my appeal to potential renters?
2 Answers
Honestly, I think leaving the tiles could work in your favor! Renters are usually used to plain white tiles or beige carpets, so your stormy green is a nice upgrade without being too bold. Plus, renovations before selling typically yield better returns than those before renting. Styles change so fast—who knows what will be in vogue in 10 years? Tile can last forever, so if it’s in good shape, you might want to keep it.
I get the feeling that teal has its own moment, but it still boils down to personal taste. If the tiles don’t match well with fixtures or cabinets, it'll look mismatched. Painting cabinets to match can work, but make sure it’s done right; cheap jobs won’t last in a rental. The racing stripe backsplash? Definitely consider changing that. A timeless look that blends with the home’s history might attract upscale renters better. Think about using white, wood, and black palettes—those are neutral enough for tenants to add their own flair.