I'm wondering if the older Stanley hand planes, specifically types 1 through 8, are still good options for woodworking today. What should I expect in terms of their performance and usability compared to newer models?
6 Answers
There are some nice features that were introduced gradually, like the knob ridge on the casting and bigger adjustment wheels. While I still find them perfectly usable, I can see how the kidney bean hole is a red flag for some folks. Personally, I think they’re still solid tools.
They do work, but they aren't my favorites. They feel a bit like Sargent planes, lacking proper frog support at the mouth. Plus, the reverse thread adjuster can be a pain. I’ll leave the collecting to the enthusiasts.
Definitely! Those earlier models are pretty reliable. You might have to tap the lateral adjustment a bit, but that's not a major hassle, in my opinion. Overall, they operate just like the newer ones.
Yeah, some of the old ones do have reversed depth adjustments, but you get used to it after a little while.
Is this a joke? Those planes are my absolute favorites! They look great and feel fantastic to use. If you've got any extras like a No. 3 you're not using, I’d love to take it off your hands, especially if it has a corrugated sole!
I feel the same way! I’m always on the lookout for type 5s.
Yeah, they're totally fine! Just remember that pre-lateral adjustments need a little tapping to set the iron, but that's something I already do anyway!
All types work well. Honestly, I prefer the later models like the 12-16 series, but the oldies can still get the job done!
I always thought the kidney bean holes signified later models too. I’ve assumed they popped up after the war!