I'm just starting out in woodworking. Currently, my tools only include a Woodriver #4 and a Jorgensen block plane. While browsing on Facebook Marketplace, I found a Stanley #5 priced at $75 and a Stanley #6 for $100, both in decent condition. Since I'm a novice, I'm wondering if these would be a good fit for me or if they're too much. I'm also considering splurging on a Lie-Nielsen Low Angle Jack for general use while keeping my #4 for smoothing tasks. Any advice on whether these planes are overkill for someone still learning the ropes?
1 Answer
If you're mostly working with S4S stock, the #4 and #5 can handle most of your needs just fine. The Stanley No.5 is a solid choice and pretty versatile. If you're working with rough stock, grabbing a #5 with an extra cambered iron would help a lot. If you plan on doing larger projects or working with rougher materials, a #7 could be really useful for flattening and jointing. Personally, I use my #7 more often than I thought I would. As for the low angle jack planes, they have their fans, but I’ve held off on buying one since they often feel like oversized block planes to me. You can typically find a #5 and a #7 for similar money as a new low angle jack.
That's my worry too! I'm mostly sticking to S4S wood because I'm still nervous about using power tools. I didn't really grow up using much beyond a drill, so I'm cautious around saws and routers. For now, most of my projects are small, but I do want to tackle a tool chest soon. Luckily, I inherited a pretty good workbench that I've been able to get functional again.