I'm currently using a Ridgid barrel jigsaw, but I'm not a fan of the switch design—it feels less safe than having a trigger. I'm considering swapping it for a D-handle version. Is this a smart move or should I stick with what I have? Appreciate any advice!
3 Answers
I've only ever used D-handles, but now you've got me curious about barrel grips! They seem like they might offer more control for complex cuts like circles.
What’s your primary cutting style? If it involves a lot of curves, the barrel grip might be worth considering. But to me, both are pretty similar in use!
It really boils down to personal preference. I had a barrel jigsaw, didn’t care for it, and switched to a D-handle that I now love. Some of my coworkers swear by their barrel jigsaws though. If you're mostly comfortable with a jigsaw, it could be worth trying both styles to see what feels right for you.
Here are some pros and cons of both styles:
**Barrel Grip:**
- **Pros:** Your hand is closer to the work, which can give better stability and make it easier to follow curves. Great for cutting from below the workpiece.
- **Cons:** Typically an on/off switch that might not work as well for precision jobs, and can be tough on smaller hands. Adjusting angles often needs a hex key.
**D-Handle:**
- **Pros:** Generally has a variable speed trigger, which is useful for different cutting tasks, and it’s usually easier to adjust bevels without tools.
- **Cons:** Your hand’s farther from the cut, which might make it feel less stable for some users.
If you’re often cutting from below, stick with the barrel. But if you really need that variable speed, give a D-handle a try before you commit. Overall, both have their strengths, so it’s all about what fits your style!