I'm using grey barnwood as trim around my windows and doors, which will contrast against my white metal board and batten siding. The wood is quite dirty and carries some remnants from its previous life as corral boards, including horse and cow hairs. Before I start, I'm planning to wash the boards. I'm looking for advice on how to make the wood look more rustic, specifically regarding surface treatments to enhance the grain and what type of fastener to use. I'm steering clear of deck screws, possibly leaning toward 3" nails, but would love to hear any suggestions or common practices you've seen!
3 Answers
For a solid, off-the-shelf option, galvanized siding nails are probably your best bet. They work well and are pretty reliable!
You might want to consider using galvanized nails for a traditional look, but if you're aiming for that weathered vibe, plain steel nails could be a hit. Just let nature take its course, and you'll end up with some rustic streaks as the rain rusts them up. Keep in mind, though, if you aren't keen on the look later on, you can always pull the short nails out.
To really bring out the depth and texture, try a mix of torching and brushing the wood. It looks fantastic and also helps with rot resistance! I’ve researched this technique, and I’m super excited to try it myself. Plus, since I got the wood for so cheap, I won’t feel bad if it doesn’t turn out perfectly!

That sounds like a stellar plan! I never thought of torching the wood, but I'm all in for that rustic aesthetic. Let me know how it goes!