Best Method for Removing Popcorn Ceilings: Scraping vs. Drywall?

21 April 2025 3 answers
Asked by CuriousSquirrel92
Hey everyone! I came across a discussion about removing popcorn ceilings, especially when there's a chance of asbestos in the paint. In the thread, most people suggested scraping as the top choice, followed by adding another layer of drywall to cover it up. Scraping sounds super tedious and messy, while the drywall option could lower the height of the room. I was thinking – why not wet the ceiling with a sprayer first, like in the scraping method, and then cut through the tape at the corners? I could locate all the screws with a magnet and take down the drywall in sheets. Of course, I'd wear PPE while doing it. What do you all think?

Answers

ThoughtfulTina77
That’s an interesting approach! Honestly, I think testing for asbestos first is always a good move. If you find it, wearing PPE is crucial. I usually just pre-wet and get into it, but if it turns out there’s asbestos, I'd take more precautions before scraping. It makes sense to get a solid grip on your options first.
Reply to this answer
PracticalPete88
Losing height by adding drywall isn't great, especially if you're already short on space! An inch may not sound like much, but every bit counts when you're in a cramped room. I get your idea about spraying first, though – that could definitely help with removal!
Reply to this answer
HandyAndy42
Instead of adding another layer, have you thought about covering the popcorn with drywall compound? It sounds a lot simpler than tearing everything down. Just remember, you'd have to build it up quite a bit to ensure you don't end up sanding through the old paint when you start prepping for a new finish.
Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.