Can I Replace a Broken Outlet Housing Without Damaging Drywall?

Thanks everyone for the insights! It sounds like I might be able to do this without damaging my drywall if I play my cards right. I’ll disconnect the power and inspect the box to see if I can repair it or if I need to go for a different style that doesn't require stud mounting. Really appreciate the support here!

This could get tricky. New boxes are typically nailed to a stud. If you've got a sawzall, try cutting away the area around the box and nails. Focus on the stud side for easier access to the nails. Just be sure to turn off the power and confirm it's off first! Once you manage to get it off, you can replace it with an old work box that doesn’t require nailing down.

I actually think part of the faceplate broke off and is stuck to the box. If that’s the case, you can try turning off the power, unscrewing the broken plastic piece, and putting on a new faceplate. It’s a simple fix if the box itself is fine!

Yeah, it’s possible to do this without major drywall work, but it might be a bit tricky! You’ll likely need an oscillating multi-tool to cut the nails holding the box to the stud. With some maneuvering, you can pop that old box out, but you might have to chip away a bit of drywall around it. After that, consider using an ‘old work’ box which can clamp onto the drywall instead of being nailed to the stud. Just make sure you’re comfortable with handling the electrical connections – it’s pretty straightforward if you follow the steps carefully.

You might want to look into using an 'old work box.' These can be installed from the outside and clamp to the drywall instead of nailing into the stud, simplifying the process significantly!

Another quick fix is to just use a drywall screw to hold the outlet in place. It's a super easy workaround, especially if the hole is mostly gone; maybe predrilling could help!