I'm looking to make a joiner's mallet but most sources suggest using a hardwood like oak or ash. Unfortunately, I can't afford hardwood right now, as the prices for S4S oak boards are through the roof. On the other hand, I've got a decent stash of Douglas Fir that I picked up cheap from the cull wood section of my local store. Is there anything wrong with using this softwood? If a mallet made from oak lasts 30 years while one from Douglas Fir lasts only 5, I'm okay with that and would prefer to use the fir. What are your thoughts?
1 Answer
Sure, you can use Douglas Fir for your mallet! Just know that it might get dented up faster than hardwoods. If you're just looking for something to help with chiseling, it should work fine for that. Plus, it's a great way to practice making your mallet. You might want to consider using MDF for the face; it’s cheap and can help protect the mallet's surface. But overall, if it gives out quickly, you can always upgrade later!
Yeah, it's a great learning opportunity. Even if it wears out, you’ll have a better idea for your next one. Plus, experimenting is part of the fun!