I own a home built in the 1890s, and it has a 12-inch setback from my neighbor's property. Unfortunately, their land slopes toward mine, which causes significant soil heaving. I've consulted with two landscaping companies that provided different solutions for addressing this runoff issue, and I want to know which proposal might be better. One company suggested a concrete surface trench drain, while the other recommended installing a French drain further away from the house. I'd appreciate any insights! Here are the details of the proposals:
**Proposal One:**
- Build a concrete trench drain along the property's length to catch runoff. It'll have a metal grate covering it.
- Cost: $11,200
**Proposal Two:**
- Dig a 2-foot deep trench, line it with a waterproof pond barrier, add a French drain pipe, and cover it with loose rocks.
- Cost: $8,600
2 Answers
Proposal one seems more effective overall but comes with a higher cost and isn't very aesthetically pleasing. On the other hand, proposal two may look nicer and can still be effective, but make sure they plan to extend the pond liner up along your foundation wall to grade. That's key!
Redirecting runoff is definitely a smart move! Personally, I lean toward proposal two, especially if it ties in neatly with your foundation at the top. However, if your house isn't getting wet solutions like in the basement, maybe you can live with a little soil shifting? But I get that it's a nuisance with the doors getting sticky and needing adjustments! That sounds frustrating.