Corded vs. Cordless Sanding: What's the Real Difference?
Asked by CraftyNinja42
I've been using a brushless DeWalt cordless random orbital sander, and it's been good for my needs. However, I'm curious if switching to a corded sander would improve my experience, especially when I'm at the shop using a dust collection hose like I do with my DeWalt. Do corded sanders provide a significant advantage? I've heard great things about Festool, but I'm wondering if there are other solid corded options as well. What do you all think?
Answers
I bought a Mirka 6" sander along with a dust extractor about a year ago, and it’s been a top performer in my shop! Honestly, it gets more use than any other tool I own. The only downside is that the sandpaper can get pricey, which is a bummer, but totally worth it for the quality.
Reply to this answer
I've got both a corded sander and a 20V DeWalt ROS. When it comes to finish work, the corded one is definitely smoother for me. I usually grab the 20V just for quick jobs or clean-ups, but if I had to pick only one, I would stick with the corded sander for sure.
Reply to this answer
Some tools don’t really work as well cordless, especially with sanders because they have a long duty cycle. I’ve got a DeWalt corded sander that fits my budget and it’s always performed well for me. Still, I've been eyeing up Festool but it's a bit out of my pricing range. Mirka also looks good and gets solid reviews!
Reply to this answer
If you choose a high-end corded sander, you’ll likely benefit from superior dust collection. I use a rigid corded sander right now, but the dust collection isn't great. I really want to create a sanding box that connects to my dust collector; I think that could improve things significantly. But if you're already hooked up to a hose with your DeWalt, having a cord might not bog you down much at all. Just make sure the new sander feels like an upgrade worth it for you!
Reply to this answer
I’ve been using Bosch corded sanders and have never had an issue! Also, I own Festool tools like track saws and routers, which are great, but when I needed a triangular pad sander, I decided on a corded Mirka Deos Delta, and it's been fantastic for me! The vibe control and dust collection are excellent, and I definitely prefer it over Festool in this case.
Reply to this answer
Generally, corded tools deliver more consistent power, which can be a game changer, especially for sanding. I've had my share of cordless tools, but when I switched from a cordless circular saw to a corded one, the difference was clear. A corded sander will just keep going as long as you need it, and if you're running a dust hose like you mentioned, the cord becomes less of an issue. If you're considering brands, while I'm not a massive Festool fan, their sanders are in a league of their own. You might also want to check out Mirka; they’re fantastic!
DustyRider33: I was kind of expecting this answer! Now I'm hesitant to even check Festool's prices. ? I've never heard of Mirka before, though...
FestoolFan84: Festool does have some top-notch tools, but I found a Mirka sander recently and it's been a great find!
Reply to this answer
Corded sanders are often much better balanced. I had a Dewalt cordless and it worked fine, but after a while, my hands would feel tingly. Switching to a Festool made it feel so much smoother and comfortable to use.
Reply to this answer
I upgraded to a Festool dust extractor because my old shop vacuum wasn’t cutting it. The instant on/off feature with a corded tool is super handy. While I own a Bosch RO sander, I recently chose to go for a Craftsman based on a review. It turns out that it’s similar to the Dewalt but a cheaper option. I've had a great experience with it so far!
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
CuriousCrafter77: That's a good point! I’m already using a hose with my DeWalt, so maybe the cord won't be that big of a deal... What’s your take on the Rigid if it's connected to a proper dust collector?
SawdustDreamer: A sanding box sounds cool! I wonder how effective those really are, though.