I recently got an estimate ranging from $10,000 to $12,000 for converting my cast iron tub and plastic shower surround into a tiled walk-in shower in my only bathroom. The bathroom is in a 100-year-old two-story house in Northeast Ohio, with an alcove size of 60" x 30" x 84". The demo involves dealing with plaster and lath walls, along with the cast iron tub. The plumber would redo the necessary copper plumbing using PEX to fit the new setup and install a Schluter waterproofing system. The final cost might fluctuate based on the prices of tiles and fixtures I choose. Does this estimate sound reasonable? The contractor is a solo worker who was nice and detailed during our chat. He drove a Mini Cooper, and I was curious about how he handles tools and debris removal. He seemed ready to start immediately, which made me a bit wary. My stepson thinks I might be getting scammed. What do you all think?
4 Answers
You have some valid concerns here. A single guy with a small car might struggle with removing the cast iron tub safely! Also, check if his estimate is itemized; you don’t want to pay upfront without knowing what it covers. I'd advise getting additional opinions, as this guy feels a bit sketchy.
Exactly! An itemized estimate is crucial. Even if he’s been in the game for a bit, you want clarity. Sounds like he may just be figuring it all out for himself.
I’d suggest getting at least three bids and making sure each one is detailed so you can compare them fairly. Ask for photos of his previous projects too, that way you get a better idea of his quality.
It really depends on his previous work, honestly. $12k is around what I would charge for similar work in Virginia Beach, but I’m generally cheaper than most in my area. Sometimes it’s easier to keep costs down with a smaller crew.
Definitely check if he’s licensed and insured before moving forward. The Mini Cooper doesn’t raise too many red flags for me; I often take my car for bids too because it’s more fuel-efficient. As for his availability, it could be fine—some contractors have gaps in their schedules that allow for smaller projects. Just make sure you understand the bid type. Get multiple estimates and break down costs!
Yeah, I often demo heavy stuff like cast iron tubs with a sledgehammer; it’s the easiest way. But that requires experience. One person can handle it if they know what they’re doing! It’s just tough without a team sometimes. Also, upfront payments for materials are common, but he should be clear on labor costs beforehand.