I'm dealing with a big weed problem, so I've dug up my whole backyard to tackle it. Now, I'm considering using naturally dyed mulch instead of going with grass. We have a dog, but I'm confident I can train him to use a different area if needed. Plus, we have a toddler, and I think mulch could provide a nice play surface for him around his playhouse and jungle gym.
I'd love to hear your thoughts on the maintenance of mulch, how it looks after rain, how often it needs replacing, and if there are important things to consider before laying it down. If anyone has tried this in their yard, please share your experiences and pictures! Thanks! ?
3 Answers
You should definitely think about layering cardboard before applying mulch; it can help suppress those persistent weeds. Just so you know, I found out there’s a ‘glue’ that can hold mulch down against erosion from rain. Just keep in mind natural mulch will fade over time, and if you lay it down, you might still see weeds popping through, so regular weeding will still be necessary!
Honestly, I think using mulch around kids and dogs might not be the best option. I know some playgrounds use a specific type of mulch that's safe for kids. Plus, mulch might just be a hiding spot for snakes or weeds will pop right back through it. You didn’t mention your zone or whether the area gets full sun or shade — both are key for making an informed decision!
I’ve read that snakes might not be common, but better safe than sorry! It’s always good to check what type of mulch is being used in playgrounds for safety.
I’d recommend double ground mulch — it breaks down quicker and isn't full of big sticks. Just keep in mind, you'll need to top it up every year to maintain its thickness. If you're thinking of mulch, try resodding and keeping some green space for your kid and dog. It makes for a safer environment overall.

That’s smart! I would have never thought to use cardboard as a base. Sounds like a plan to get those weeds under control.