I'm looking for some advice on two quotes I've received for a new furnace and AC installation. I've shared these quotes on a few different platforms but haven't gotten much feedback yet. Here's the scoop: Company 1 offers Comfortmaker units, while Company 2 installs Goodman. Both companies quoted me for relocating the condenser to the side of the house, but Company 1's pricing is about $3,000 higher for the exact same service. It leaves me wondering whether the extra cost is justified. Here's a breakdown of the quotes:
**Company 1:**
- **Quote 1:** $15,000 total (approx. $3,500 to move the AC)
- Furnace: Single Stage 80% efficient
- AC: Standard 14.0 SEER 2.5 Tons
- No smart thermostat
- 10 year warranty
- **Quote 2:** $24,450 total (approx. $3,500 to move the AC)
- Furnace: Two Stage 96% efficient
- AC: 17 SEER
- Smart WiFi thermostat
- 10 year warranty
- **Quote 3:** $20,875 total (same as Quote 2 but with single stage furnace)
**Company 2:**
- **Quote:** $9,150 total (approx. $500 to move the AC)
- Furnace: Two Stage 96% efficient Goodman
- AC: 14 SEER 2.5 ton Goodman
- WiFi digital thermostat
- Comprehensive warranty package
Given that the brands and efficiencies differ, is it worth paying so much more with Company 1? Or should I just go with the more affordable quote from Company 2?
1 Answer
When it comes to HVAC systems, the install quality typically trumps the brand itself. Since performance can vary significantly based on who's doing the work, I suggest you check reviews for Company 2. If they have solid feedback—and given their long history with servicing your current units—that could make them a safe bet! In warmer climates, the SEER rating is crucial, though. If you're in a cooler region, the differences might not matter as much.
Thanks for the insight! Company 2 does have a good reputation, and since they've been keeping my old system running, I'm leaning towards them.