I'm setting up a new shop in my 1.5 car garage after buying my first house, and I'm torn between getting a bandsaw or a table saw. I've mostly used hand tools for the past couple of years, but now I want to introduce some power tools since I have the space. I have some projects planned like built-ins and cabinets, and I'm leaning towards a table saw for its ease of making precise cuts and repeatability for jobs like shaker doors. However, I'm also considering a bandsaw because of its versatility and how it complements hand tool work. Would going with a bandsaw complicate my projects or slow me down? Plus, I'm also thinking about my budget for dust collection and other upgrades. Any thoughts?
7 Answers
If your projects are mainly cabinetry and built-ins, I’d say a table saw will speed things up and provide the clean cuts you need. Sure, you can do a lot with a bandsaw, but for repeatable dimensions and cutting sheet goods, the table saw is the more efficient option. You can always add a bandsaw later as you expand your shop.
If you're primarily working with hand tools, a bandsaw would be a solid choice! It excels at ripping, resawing, and cutting curves, making it much more versatile for hand tool woodworking. While a table saw is nice to have, you can often get by without one, especially if you adapt your techniques with a bandsaw.
Yeah, I have both and use them for different purposes. For building furniture and dealing with large panels, I still find the table saw to be a workhorse. But the bandsaw is fantastic for more intricate work and is safer for new users, especially when learning to use machinery.
One point to think about is safety. I've heard a lot about schools not allowing students to use table saws because of the risks involved. If you're teaching others, that might steer you more towards the bandsaw for their safety. Just something to consider as you plan your shop setup!
I recently faced a similar situation, and I chose the table saw for sheet goods while keeping my bandsaw for curves and resawing. Each tool has its place, but for cabinetry, you’ll definitely find a table saw will make your life easier. Also, consider a track saw if you're working with larger panels—it could be a game changer in a tight space!
Definitely go with the bandsaw! It's super versatile for handtool-focused projects and takes care of resawing, which can be a hassle with hand tools. While some might argue for a table saw for cabinetry work, the bandsaw will serve you just fine—plus, you'll find it easier to handle overall.
Yeah! Just be sure to get a robust one for resawing thicker materials, and don’t forget about dust collection—it's just as important with a bandsaw!
You know, while the bandsaw can be safer for a lot of projects, don’t overlook the utility of a table saw, especially for sheet goods like plywood. If your projects involve a lot of cabinet making or big sheets, a table saw really is hard to beat for efficiency. Just be aware of the safety aspect—it's crucial, especially with apprentices around.
Good reminder! I’ve seen some workshops avoid table saws for safety reasons, opting for bandsaws instead. It's always a balancing act between the tools’ capabilities and their safety—especially when teaching others.
I agree! Bandsaws are great for flexibility, and you'll really appreciate it if you're doing curved cuts. Plus, with a good setup, a bandsaw can handle most of your woodworking needs without the safety concerns that come with table saws.