I'm looking for some advice on whether to stick with a traditional 75-gallon water heater or switch to a tankless model. I've received quotes from a plumbing company for both options:
1. **75-Gallon Power Vent:** $5,378
- Includes draining and removing the existing unit, adapting piping, installing a new power vent, and more.
- Comes with a 6-year manufacturer warranty and a 1-year installation warranty.
2. **Navien 240A Tankless:** $5,812
- Similar installation steps, including drainage and adapting piping. Has an extra option for a PH neutralizer for $199.
- Also has a 6-year manufacturer warranty and a 1-year installation warranty.
Considering that the costs are pretty close, I'm leaning towards keeping the laundry running while taking a shower, but I'm open to suggestions. What do you think is the better option?
3 Answers
Have you thought about a heat pump water heater? They often come with great rebates and could save you a good amount on utility bills. Just keep in mind where you live and the location of your current water heater. Electric tankless ones can be pricey to run, and gas tankless can be troublesome for climate impact and insurance rates. You definitely want to consider those factors!
I gotta recommend going for the tankless! I've switched to one, and the advantage of unlimited hot water is just fantastic. If the costs are about the same, tankless is where it's at. Trust me, as someone who loves long showers, it’s truly a game changer!
It might be worthwhile to get a couple more quotes just to compare options fully. Prices can vary a lot between contractors, and you could end up saving some cash. Also, check if there are any local grants or incentives for switching to tankless—it could make the transition more affordable!

Definitely agree! The flexibility and endless hot water are totally worth it. Just make sure you’re on top of regular maintenance to keep everything running smoothly.