I'm faced with a tricky situation. I hired a contractor, let's call him Bill, to do some roof repairs on my new home. One of his subcontractors, Joe, mentioned that the back roof needs replacement and offered to do it for $4000 if I went directly through him, claiming that Bill might charge me around $6000. After the initial repairs were done, Bill confirmed that Joe thought the back roof needed work too and offered to handle it. Since Joe is the one doing the actual work, I'm wondering if I should go directly with him or stick with Bill, who has been reliable and responsive. I appreciate Bill's help and even recommended him to others. I could also handle getting the materials myself, which might lower the costs. Both Bill and Joe are licensed and bonded, but I'm concerned about the potential fallout in my relationship with Bill. What do you think I should do?
3 Answers
Honestly, I'd be careful about going behind Bill's back. It's likely to sour your relationship, especially if you plan to work with him again in the future. Consider what the risks are, especially with insurance and warranties. I'd focus more on that than just saving a couple grand.
Totally agree! Building a good relationship with a contractor is worth more than saving a bit on one job.
If I were you, I'd ask Bill if he ever hires out Joe for side jobs. It keeps everything above board and you get to work with someone you trust. Just don’t mention Joe’s offer directly. And remember, going with Joe might save you money, but you lose the protections that come with going through Bill.
That's a solid approach. If Joe does good work, I'm sure Bill would want to know. Plus, getting materials yourself can always help reduce costs.
Exactly! And if you’re providing materials, you could negotiate better with Bill, maybe get a fairer deal.
Honestly, I think Joe's trying to pull a fast one on Bill, showing some bad character there. If you're happy with Bill's work, I'd stay loyal to him unless he really disappoints you. Even then, it might be better to communicate openly with him.
For sure! If Joe’s willing to undercut like that, who knows how he’ll handle your project. I'd want the accountability that comes with a good GC.
Definitely. Open communication always saves you from headaches later on!
Yeah, it could cost more in the long run if Bill decides not to work with you anymore. You mentioned he's been helpful, so I'd talk to him first about your options.