I've been doing a lot of research but I'm stuck in analysis paralysis about my router situation. Right now, I have a Milwaukee trim router but I've come to realize that a plunge base is pretty necessary for the work I want to do. The plunge base costs around $130. I'm worried that my current router might not handle mortises and dados well enough. Should I just bite the bullet and buy the plunge base, or would it be smarter to sell my Milwaukee (hoping to get about $100) and then purchase the Bosch 1617, which comes with both bases for about $200? This Bosch router also has 2.25hp and can handle 1⁄2 inch and 1⁄4 inch bits, even though it's corded. I'd really appreciate any advice!
6 Answers
I'd suggest keeping your trim router and getting the bigger Bosch. The trim router is great for smaller, more manageable tasks, while the Bosch can handle more demanding jobs—plus, they're both solid brands that’ll last a while!
You might not really need a plunge router for most projects. What exactly are you planning to tackle? I've got three routers and the plunge base is something I hardly ever use.
I started with the Bosch 1617 and then bought a DeWalt cordless trim router later on. I don’t use the Bosch for lighter tasks like rounding over coasters, but it's perfect for bigger jobs like dados on window frames when my table saw isn't an option.
If it's in your budget, keep the trim router and add the Bosch to your collection. It's super useful to have both—a trim router for everyday tasks and a more powerful one for heavy-duty jobs like flattening or plunging mortises.
Well, if you can swing it, it sounds like having both is the best option. I use mine for different tasks—my corded one for bigger jobs and my trim router for lighter stuff.
Having more power is definitely a plus, especially when it comes to plunging for mortises. I recommend considering a router that allows for 1⁄2 inch bits; they tend to be safer and sturdier.