I've got a 40 Gallon US Craftmaster Natural Gas Water Heater from 1995, and it's still chugging along without any issues! My inspector told me years ago just to let it run until it dies since they don't make them like they used to. I live in a suburb of Saint Louis MO with decent water quality, and I've always followed his advice, even skipping maintenance like draining it to avoid potential problems. However, now that it's 30 years old, I'm starting to wonder if it's time to finally consider a replacement. If it died unexpectedly, I could manage for a bit without hot water, and my set up is pretty safe from leaks. I'm curious if I should start looking for a new water heater, maybe even a hybrid instead of sticking with natural gas? Brand recommendations would be appreciated, and do you guys agree with the inspector about draining it or should I take care of that myself? Thanks!
3 Answers
Honestly, you've squeezed a good amount of life out of that water heater! With it being 30 years old, I’d lean towards replacing it sooner rather than waiting for a failure. New heaters aren’t too pricey, and gas models are still pretty solid if that's your choice.
I mean, I’m all for running it until it dies too, but you've got to think about the potential mess if it fails. Maybe consider installing some smart leak detectors in your basement just in case. They can notify you before it becomes a bigger issue!
Great advice! I did that with my basement setup, and it's a lifesaver. Makes you a bit more at ease when you’re away.
You are definitely living on borrowed time at this point! I highly recommend switching to a heat pump water heater. They’re energy-efficient, save you money in the long run, and you'll still have enough hot water for your needs. Plus, check out any rebates in your area—they can help with the cost!
Right? I'm in the same boat and worried about just waiting for a disaster. But I hear ya, sounds tempting to just ride it out until it dies.