What’s the Best Heating System to Replace Electric Baseboard Heat?

I definitely recommend keeping the baseboard heaters for those -15°F days. A friend of mine switched to just a heat pump, and they regretted getting rid of their baseboards. You’ll only need them a handful of times each winter, but it could save you from being really cold!

How about going for geothermal with floor heating? It’s super efficient and keeps your house nice and warm without the hassle of traditional systems.

I have a mini-split heat pump, and it works fine even down to about -20°C. On those rare really cold days, I just turn on the baseboards for extra support. Also, I enjoy the added AC functionality in summer!

Changing to a different heating system will involve some significant work, whether it be ductwork or floor renovations. Just remember, heat pumps are really similar to AC systems on the outside; you'll still need ducts or some air handlers for distribution. If your concern is dust and air quality, a zoned setup might help, but you still need to move air around to some extent.

Replacing your system with something similar is typically the most cost-effective route. A mini-split heat pump could be a great option since it offers heating and cooling capabilities. It's also much more efficient than electric baseboards when the temperature is above 20°F. Plus, it helps with your air quality concern if you keep the system zoned!

I installed a wood stove in my place a couple of years ago and I can't see myself going back to anything else! It really adds a cozy touch and warmth during the winter.

If I were you, I'd go with a heat pump and keep the baseboard heaters as a backup for those super cold days. It’s a solid combo that gives you flexibility!