I'm currently at an impasse with my spouse about the best flooring choice for our house. We live in a hot climate, have two little kids (both under 3), and two elderly dogs—one of which has incontinence issues. We want to install flooring in our open-concept kitchen, half bath, pantry, and living/dining room. My spouse believes tile is the way to go, especially since they found a promising option, while I'm leaning towards Luxury Vinyl Plank (LVP) instead. What do you think is the best long-lasting option? Can tile really be considered timeless?
6 Answers
In my opinion, real hardwood will always be in style. I’m talking about quality, thick oak that can be refinished, not the engineered stuff. Sure, LVP is convenient but it doesn't hold up as well in the long run. If you ever have to replace it, that can be a hassle.
You can't go wrong with classic white tile in bathrooms—it's timeless! Just think about how it might work in your open areas too.
Honestly, I think it really depends on your home's vibe. Certain options like terracotta hex tiles might not be universally stylish, but they definitely have a place in certain homes. If your place has a lot of character, maybe tile could work. Otherwise, it can be hit or miss.
I have to say, high-quality LVP has its charms! It tends to feel nicer underfoot than some tile. Now, there’s no true definition of "timeless" when it comes to style since trends change, but if you’re not too concerned about fads, LVP might just last you a lifetime! Plus, it’s way easier for DIY installations, which is a big plus.
And with kids around, LVP might be the smarter move for wear and tear!
You might want to check out Sam's Club for some decent LVP! It's spill-resistant and rated to withstand liquid for a while without damage. Plus, tile tends to be much colder and pricier—especially with small kids and aging dogs, LVP could save you a lot of headaches with maintenance and comfort.
For a long-lasting option, consider high-end wood look tiles. They can give you the warmth of wood with the durability of tile. I’ve installed a similar style in my home and love it! It holds up well and looks fantastic—might be worth checking out options online!
Wow, they look just like real wood from the photos! I wasn’t sold on tile until this.

Yeah, our house is pretty generic suburban, so not sure how well that would fit.