Which is Worse for Walls: Heavy Duty Tape or Thumbtacks?

9 June 2025 2 answers
Asked by CuriousCat42
I'm curious about what most people think; do you believe heavy duty tape is more damaging to wall paint than using thumbtacks? And I wonder which option is considered more unattractive by landlords or parents of kids.

Answers

WallWarrior99
Honestly, I think heavy duty tape is worse for your walls. It can really pull off paint and even the top layer of drywall. Meanwhile, a tiny hole from a thumbtack is super easy to fix. You could even use things like caulk or spackle to patch it up without a problem.

RepairPro29: Totally agree! I've had experience with both, and the tape has ruined my walls before, while the tiny holes from thumbtacks are no big deal.

Reply to this answer
TeacherVinny
As a teacher for about 15 years, I've noticed that thumbtacks usually cause less damage than tape. They leave behind small holes, but those are way easier to deal with than the mess tape can create.
Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.